AddThis  

Logo Gadgetize

Not announcements - real, available gadgets and gizmos. If you read about it here, you can buy it. Probably.

Compare Prices on Gadgets at Spot Cost

Search     for     

Site Search

  

Previous Posts

» A Day With Kindle and a Free Kindle Book
» Too Good to Pass Up - Pen Spy Camera $25
» MicroSD Adapters for Cheap - $2 Delivered
» Is this a gadget? The PedEgg rules.
» Samsung Messager vs. Kyocera Lingo -- No Contest
» Intriguing 8GB Insignia Pilot Bluetooth Player - $100
» Almost Gone-- 24" Soyo DYLM24D6 $220 Shipped
» Loving Imageshack's Torrent Service
» Free Standalone File Recovery
» Inoi HV670 DVD/HDD Media Player for $80


Related Products

Archives

» January 2005
» February 2005
» March 2005
» May 2005
» June 2005
» July 2005
» August 2005
» September 2005
» October 2005
» November 2005
» December 2005
» January 2006
» February 2006
» March 2006
» July 2006
» August 2006
» September 2006
» October 2006
» November 2006
» January 2007
» May 2007
» June 2007
» July 2007
» August 2007
» October 2007
» January 2008
» April 2008
» May 2008
» September 2008
» December 2008
» February 2009

Thursday, September 04, 2008

Samsung Messager vs. Kyocera Lingo -- No Contest

MessagerWell, I'm stuck with it, and yeah it looks better than the Lingo, but how is the Messager in daily use?

First I'll cover the nice stuff. The Messager has a nice interface and a nice chassis. It is better looking all around. And it was easy to add my own ringtones either via HTTP or vie MMS message. So far so good. Call quality? Very nice. The reason I picked it up in the first place was that my Lingo was dropping calls, probably because of repeated drops over time. The Messager is a tri-band phone that will supposedly be able to take advantage of a larger call area. Nice.

MessagerUnfortunately, the fun ended there. In literally every other way I use the phone, my cheaper, uglier, chintzier Kyocera Lingo blows the Messager away-

1) The Keyboard: The Lingo's keyboard is simply better laid out, and faster to type with in both SMS and email. The selector buttons are at the bottom of the keyboard instead of lined up with the screen, the arrow buttons are way down in the bottom right where it's tougher to access by touch, and the shift and function keys work like a shift-lock, requiring repeated presses before and after punctuation. Parens are at least 3 screens of menus away, the comma requires the function key, and instead of centering the keyboard it skews left as you go down. Also, no Enter key that I can find for typing emails. The Lingo keyboard, while cheap looking and squeaky, is separated into halves and is just easier to use in every situation.

2) The Apps and Internet: The Messager can't use the Internet or Java apps without sliding the keyboard open. What? Why? I could check Gmail on my Lingo in the regular phone position, yes, while driving. And now even if I can eventually get the Java Gmail working, I have to slide out the keyboard to use it. Stupid.

3. Browser: I've set it a number of times, and nothing I do can keep the service provide home page from launching every time I start up the browser. OK fine. At least it'll open the last page I had open, like the Lingo? Nope. So the browser startup, before I can interact with it, takes probably a minute longer than the Lingo did. The Lingo immediately showed whatever I last had open. From there I can at least request what I need, instead of waiting for something I definitely don't.

So since I can't return my Samsung Messager, I am going to hang my hat on what it does have. Good call quality, a MicroSD slot, and a nice-looing (not working) interface. Oh, and I can set ringtones for each caller, which I will do.

Gotta make myself not feel like an idiot, but I do miss my crappy looking little gold Kyocera Lingo. Maybe they'll make a sequel and this Messager will break.

Labels: , , ,

AddThis Permalink   Email This   Post a Comment (1)

© Gadgetize.com All Rights Reserved. Besides, there's nada to copy.

Gadget Saving

» Froogle - Shopping Search
» SpotCost - Price Comparison
 

Gadget Shopping

» Computer Geeks
» New Egg
» Cyber Outlet
» Directron
 

Gadget Blogs

» Engadget
» Gizmodo
» Gotta Have One
» Oh Gizmo

Tags / Labels